[Translate to English:] Laptop
Newsletter data protection

Newsletter data protection 11/2026

“Data protection law is part of the highway code on the great data motorways of our time”, said the new Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI), Prof Dr Moritz Hennemann, on taking office. With this in mind, in this newsletter we aim to inform you about the understanding and development of the fundamental concept of ‘personal data’, so that you can navigate the ‘traffic of data protection law’ safely and in compliance with the law.

This month, we also report on a referral by the BGH to the ECJ regarding the interpretation of the so-called ‘household exception’. In another judgement, the BGH addressed a further exception under the GDPR, namely the ‘media privilege’. Furthermore, the LG Cologne ruled that data processing by an AI chatbot was unlawful. The administrative courts have also been dealing with data protection law: the VG Berlin considered the disclosure of data on vaccination status to the public health authority, whilst the VG Wiesbaden dealt with a claim for the data protection authority to take action. We also report on the latest activities of the DSK and the EDSA, and how it came about that several fines running into millions were imposed.

If you have any feedback on this newsletter or any questions regarding its topics, please email us at datenschutz@brandi.net. You can also find further contact details on our website.

Dr. Sebastian Meyer and the BRANDI Data Protection Team

Dr. Sebastian Meyer, LL.M.

Lawyer and Notary in and for Bielefeld
Certified Specialized Attorney in information technology law (IT-Recht)
Data Protection Auditor (TÜV)

Information and contact

Topic of the month / November 2026

The term ‘personal data’ and its evolution

The central focus of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) is the processing of personal data. Whilst this may sound self-evident, it repeatedly causes difficulties for many organisations and raises questions. When does data cease to be personal? When does it constitute a category of particularly sensitive data? What is the difference between anonymised and pseudonymised data? Since the GDPR came into force in 2018, the concept of personal data has been shaped by case law, whilst data protection authorities and European data protection institutions have also commented on this concept during this period. Whether data is classified as personal data determines the applicability of the GDPR and entails, amongst other things, information and documentation obligations, as well as the obligation to implement appropriate security measures. Companies should also be familiar with the concept of personal data when assessing the risk to data subjects arising from data processing.

Other topics in this newsletter

Federal Court of Justice

Reference to the European Court of Justice regarding the so-called ‘household exception’

By order of September 17, 2026, the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) referred questions to the European Court of Justice (ECJ) for interpretation regarding the scope of the so-called ‘household exception’ in Article 2(2)(c) of the GDPR (BGH, order dated 17.09.2026 – Ref. I ZR 256/25 and I ZR 289/25). This order for a preliminary ruling joins two cases.

Both cases concerned the applicability of Article 2(2)(c) of the GDPR, according to which the GDPR does not apply to the processing of personal data carried out solely for the purposes of personal or family matters.

The first case concerns the forwarding of a private chat message to the claimant’s employer. The claimant had made negative remarks about her employer in a private conversation with the defendant. Following a falling-out between the parties, the defendant forwarded the correspondence exchanged with the claimant to the claimant’s employer, whereupon she was dismissed. The Frankfurt Regional Court ruled, as sought, that the defendant was liable to pay damages to the claimant. The Court of Appeal amended the judgment and dismissed the claim.

The second case concerns the video surveillance of a shared kitchen-diner. The video recordings made in this way served as evidence in legal proceedings concerning the possible theft of coins within a family. The claimant – the mother, who lives in the same house – sought an injunction against the defendant daughter and, at the same time, claimed damages. The Regional Court dismissed the claim; the appeal was also unsuccessful.

However, the BGH has not followed the case law of the lower courts, but has referred the matter to the ECJ. The ECJ is to clarify whether a ‘family-related’ activity always requires a geographical or other connection to the household of the person processing the data. 

Lutz Renneke

Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter

BGH on the media privilege

On September 29, 2026, the BGH ruled that the taking and passing on of photographs to the press for the purpose of publication falls within the scope of the media privilege (BGH, decision dated 29.09.2026 – Ref. VI ZR 402/24).

The claimant – a German singer – was secretly photographed whilst walking through Munich city centre with her daughter. The photographs were sold by the photographer to various editorial offices and published by them. The singer subsequently brought an action seeking, amongst other things, compensation for non-pecuniary damage under Article 82(1) of the GDPR on the grounds of the photographer’s taking and disclosure of the photographs.

The court recognised both the taking of the photographs and their disclosure to the editorial offices as processing of personal data within the meaning of the GDPR. In the Federal Court of Justice’s view, the lawfulness of the data processing should not be assessed against Article 6 of the GDPR, but rather falls under the media privilege pursuant to Article 85(2) of the GDPR in conjunction with the relevant national state laws. Accordingly, Member States may provide for derogations or exceptions from certain data protection requirements for data processing for journalistic purposes, in order to reconcile the protection of personal data with the freedom of expression and freedom of information.

In the Court’s view, the concept of journalistic purposes is to be interpreted broadly. Under the new legal framework, in particular, data processing no longer needs to be carried out exclusively for the organisation’s own journalistic and editorial purposes. In this context, the BGH emphasised that freedom of the media remains a fundamental pillar of the free democratic basic order, even in the age of digitalisation. Furthermore, the court refers to the case law of the ECJ, according to which the mere purpose of disseminating information, opinions or ideas to the public, irrespective of the means of transmission, is already covered (ECJ, decision dated 14.02.2019 – Ref. C-345/17). Consequently, in the BGH’s view, preparatory activities – including the gathering of information – are already covered by data processing for journalistic purposes. As the editorial teams had edited the content of the photographs taken and incorporated them into press articles, the required minimum level of independent editorial processing of the information provided had been met. The BGH did not award the claimant any damages under data protection law.

Cologne Regional Court

Court halts data use by AI chatbot

On September 17, 2026, the Cologne Regional Court ruled that the collection and processing of sensitive personal data by Snapchat’s ‘My AI’ chatbot contravenes data protection law (Cologne Regional Court, decision dated 17.09.2026 – Ref. 33 O 120/24; press release of 15.10.2026). Furthermore, the court criticised the Snap Group for breaching youth protection laws by displaying advertising content relating to alcohol and gambling to minors. 

Snapchat is an instant messaging service that is particularly popular amongst minors, with the primary function of exchanging photos and videos. Users can also send direct messages, save recordings and share their locations.

The lawsuit stems from an initiative by the Federal Association of Consumer Organisations. In particular, the association criticised the fact that, when asked, the chatbot encouraged the consumption of alcohol, regardless of the user’s age. 

‘My AI’ is a ChatGPT-based chatbot within the app that automatically answers users’ questions. The application includes a notice stating that data entered may be used to personalise relevant advertisements. In practice, this had led to the comprehensive processing of all user input. In addition to voice messages and photos, this also included the processing of particularly sensitive personal data, such as information on religion or sexual orientation. The processing of such data is prohibited under Article 9(1) of the GDPR, unless the data subject has given explicit consent or one of the other legal bases set out in Article 9 of the GDPR applies. 

Snapchat never obtained valid consent. In the app’s settings, all options relating to ‘advertising preferences’ were already preset, meaning that they did not meet the strict GDPR requirements for legally compliant consent. 

In the case of online services directed specifically at minors, such as Snapchat, appropriate consent for those under the age of 16 must also be given by their legal representatives. However, the operator had not provided for such consent from the outset.

The defendant argued that it did not intentionally collect the sensitive data, as this was, rather, ‘imposed’ by the chatbot users. The Regional Court, however, dismissed this argument as irrelevant: what is decisive, it held, is solely the objective storage and processing of the data, regardless of the underlying intention. 

The judgement is not yet final.

Felix Sander

Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter

Berlin Administrative Court

Fire service was entitled to report staff without proof of vaccination

On September 30, 2026, the Berlin Administrative Court ruled in three cases that the Berlin Fire Service was permitted to report employees to the public health authority if they could not provide proof of vaccination or recovery from SARS-CoV-2 (Berlin Administrative Court, decision dated 30.09.2026 – Ref. VG 42 K 72/25, VG 42 K 65/25 and VG 42 K 66/25; press release of 05.10.2026). The report that the employees also been in direct contact with members of vulnerable groups was assessed differently.

To contain the COVID-19 pandemic, a facility-based vaccination requirement applied from March 16, to December 31, 2022 pursuant to Section 20a of the Infection Protection Act (IfSG), under which employees in healthcare and care facilities were required to provide evidence that they had been vaccinated, had recovered from the virus, or were unvaccinated for medical reasons. Consequently, the Berlin Fire Brigade reported staff who failed to provide the requisite proof to the State Office for Health and Social Affairs (LaGeSo). The facility-specific obligation to provide proof under the IfSG applied to staff of the fire and rescue service regardless of their specific role within the facility; consequently, in the court’s view, the disclosure of vaccination status did not give rise to any objections under data protection law.

For the reporting, the Berlin Fire Service used a questionnaire provided by LaGeSo and ticked ‘Yes’ across the board for all fire service personnel in response to the question of whether employees had direct contact with vulnerable groups. However, some of the fire service officers concerned carried out office-based duties and were not engaged in field work. According to the Berlin Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BlnBDI), the statement was therefore incorrect and contravened the principle of accuracy (Article 5(1)(d) of the GDPR). The Administrative Court has now upheld the BlnBDI’s warning.

The claim for damages brought by two fire service officers could therefore only be based on the incorrect statement regarding contact with vulnerable groups and not on the rest of the report. The psychological distress cited as grounds for the claim was based on a ‘loss of control’ over personal data. The court deemed compensation of 100 euros to be appropriate.

Wiesbaden Administrative Court

Data protection authority may await the ECJ’s decision

In a judgement of August 28, 2026, the Wiesbaden Administrative Court addressed the question of whether supervisory authorities may suspend proceedings and await the decision of the ECJ (Wiesbaden Administrative Court, decision dated 28.08.2026 – Ref. 6 K 139/24.WI).

The claimant lodged a complaint with the competent data protection authority regarding a website operator’s cookie banner and data transfers to third countries. The data protection authority replied to the claimant that the cookie banner was based on the Transparency and Consent Framework – a technical and legal standard – provided by a third-party provider, which was already the subject of a preliminary ruling procedure before the ECJ. As a uniform approach within the EU would be required once the proceedings were concluded, the data protection authority stated that it would contact the claimant of its own accord once the proceedings had ended. Referring to a statement from the website operator, the data protection authority also pointed out to the claimant that the third-country third-party provider was no longer integrated into the website and that, consequently, no data transfers to third countries were currently taking place. The Data Protection Authority would also contact the claimant of its own accord in this regard once the supervisory proceedings had been concluded. Furthermore, the settings of the cookie banner had been amended. The claimant subsequently brought a general action for performance, seeking action by the Data Protection Authority.

Under Article 78(2) of the GDPR, data subjects have the right to an effective judicial remedy if the competent supervisory authority fails to deal with a complaint or has not informed the data subject of the status or outcome within three months. However, a final decision is not required within this time limit.

The court found that the data protection authority had taken action within the three-month time limit and that its reply, stating that it was awaiting the decision of the ECJ, constituted a statement of the current status of the case. In the court’s view, the proceedings could be stayed in order to avoid conflicting decisions; this was a legitimate aim under Recitals 10 and 129 of the GDPR. The ECJ has since delivered a judgment; however, as the grounds for the judgment have not yet been published, no consultation has yet taken place between the data protection authorities. The administrative discretion under Section 10 of the Administrative Procedure Act (HVwVfG) does, however, cover the postponement of the conclusion of the supervisory proceedings. In the Administrative Court’s view, an ongoing status update at three-monthly intervals is neither necessary nor expedient. Furthermore, the separation and joinder of proceedings also fall within the supervisory authority’s discretion; consequently, according to the Administrative Court, there was no need for a separate final decision on the transfer to a third country concerning the same website. Referring to the case law of the ECJ (ECJ, decision dated 07.12.2023 – Ref. C-26/22; decision dated 26.09.2024 – Ref. C-768/21), the court explained that the data protection authority could, for example, refrain from imposing remedial measures if the identified data protection breach, as in the present case, had not continued.

The action was dismissed as unfounded.

New Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information, Prof. Dr Moritz Hennemann

On September 29, 2026, Prof. Dr Moritz Hennemann was appointed as the new Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) (press release of 01.10.2026). Hennemann is a qualified lawyer and, until taking up his post, held a chair in civil law, information law, media law and internet law at the University of Freiburg. He also headed the Institute for Media and Information Law and served part-time as a judge at the Higher Regional Court of Karlsruhe.

At the Federal Press Conference on October 6, 2026, the new BfDI then outlined the key priorities for his term of office (press release of 06.10.2026). In addition to providing data protection guidance on efforts to achieve digital sovereignty for Germany and the EU, the aim is also to monitor ‘technological leaps’, particularly in connection with artificial intelligence, with a strategic and forward-looking approach. Hennemann welcomed current reform debates in data protection law concerning the Digital Omnibus and a Data Code, as well as considerations regarding the consolidation of data protection supervision within the BfDI; however, he also criticised proposed legislative amendments to the Freedom of Information Act as “undermining the right to freedom of information” and emphasised its importance for democracy. Finally, Hennemann highlighted the BfDI’s advisory role: “All organisations are entitled to solution-oriented and targeted advice”.

DSK and EDPB on smart glasses

Both the Data Protection Conference (DSK) and the European Data Protection Board (EDPB) have, in recent months, addressed issues concerning the protection of personal data and the rights and freedoms of individuals in connection with the increasing availability and use of smart glasses.

The DSK discussed the topic at its conference on September 24, 2026, based on a prior interdisciplinary review carried out by the Hamburg Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (HmbBfDI). The review, which covered both technical and data protection aspects, concluded that, with the exception of rare cases, the recording of individuals using smart glasses cannot be justified on the grounds of a legitimate interest or – in the absence of transparency – informed consent (HmbBfDI, final report dated 10.09.2026). The DSK took note of this report and endorsed its findings (press release of 24.09.2026), emphasising in particular that the obligations under the GDPR also apply to private individuals outside the scope of the household exemption. Not everything that is technically possible is also permissible under data protection law. In this regard, it is primarily up to manufacturers to design technology in such a way that data protection requirements can actually be implemented. At the same time, however, the potential of this new technical development is also recognised.

The EDPB has also adopted an expert report (‘The connected gaze: Video recording, surveillance and administering evidence in the age of smart glasses’), which examines the user experience of smart glasses and awareness of the associated risks. In addition, the EDPB published a statement (statement release of 13.10.2026) on the challenges relating to data protection. Depending on the use, different parties may be considered responsible for data processing, namely the user, the manufacturer and/or the provider, either as separate or joint controllers. Transparency issues relating to usage are highlighted as a particular challenge: recordings must be clearly recognisable to the data subjects.

Denmark

Unknown individuals steal eleven million records from the national population register

The Central Population Register (CPR) is Denmark’s central population register, established in 1968, which plays a vital role in public administration and the everyday lives of all the country’s residents. 

Every person registered in Denmark is assigned a lifelong, ten-digit personal identification number, which is used in everyday life, at the doctor’s, in pharmacies, at banks and when dealing with public authorities. The master data includes, amongst other things, an individual personal identification number, name, address, date of birth, nationality, religious affiliation and marital status. Furthermore, the personal CPR number is closely linked to the Danish e-health system, the equivalent of a digital patient record. 

The Population Register contains data on around eleven million people. The system therefore records not only all persons registered in Denmark, but also records relating to emigrants and deceased persons. 

The hackers did not access the data directly via government servers. Instead, over a period of around ten days, they exploited corporate access granted to a small software firm. In total, 1,039 Danish companies have legitimate access to the register for authorised purposes. However, the system did not provide for two-factor authentication. Furthermore, the authorised companies were able to choose their own passwords, with the result that one administrator simply set the easily hackable password ‘123456’.

Using a programme written by artificial intelligence, the perpetrators sent millions of requests to the register. It was only when a subsequent invoice itemised the requests individually that the unauthorised access was detected. 

The Minister for Digital Affairs, Ms Egelund, described it as an “extremely serious incident”, but emphasised that vulnerable individuals who had applied for an address block due to stalking or threats were not affected. 

The incident casts a shadow over the Danes’ otherwise seamlessly digitised everyday lives. It highlights just how crucial secure two-factor authentication and passwords that are difficult to hack are today. 

Felix Sander

Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter

Italy

€ 7 million fine for unlawful processing of health data

On September 23, 2026, the Italian Data Protection Authority (GPDP) imposed a fine of 7,000,000 euros on IQVIA Solutions Italy S.r.l. for the unlawful processing of health data (press release of 02.10.2026).

IQVIA is a group company operating in the field of health data analysis and clinical research. To conduct studies, the company uses a database containing health data from approximately 1 million patients referred by 800 doctors.

Contrary to the company’s claims, the authority found that the data was not anonymous. Patients had been assigned a permanent identifier, which made it possible to track them over an extended period. Furthermore, the patients could be identified in conjunction with other factors – such as year of birth, diagnoses and prescriptions. In addition, the database stored information that led to the direct identification of approximately 3,370 patients.

The authority took the view that the health data had been processed without a legal basis and without adequate security measures, that the obligations to inform patients had been breached, and that no retention periods had been defined. Furthermore, IQVIA had not carried out a data protection impact assessment.

In determining the amount of the fine, the high number of data subjects affected and the sensitivity of the health data were taken into account; conversely, the company’s cooperation during the fine proceedings acted as a mitigating factor. Should the company wish to continue processing the data, it must bring its processing activities into line with the requirements of the GDPR within 120 days.

Croatia

Fine of € 2.6 million for the processing of biometric data

On October 2 2026, the Croatian Data Protection Authority (AZOP) imposed a fine of 2,590,000 euros on Priređivač igara na sreću for the unlawful processing of biometric data (press release of 02.10.2026).

The company operates gambling services. In addition to checking identity documents, the company introduced the option of scanning RFID chips or fingerprints to identify players. Four fingerprints were used for this purpose.

In the authority’s view, the collection of four fingerprints exceeds the scope of personal data necessary to achieve the purpose of identifying players. The AZOP did not accept the gambling operator’s argument that the additional fingerprints were necessary to prevent faulty or failed scans due to skin damage. In the authority’s view, the player’s consent was also irrelevant and did not remedy the breach of the principle of data minimisation. According to the AZOP, this applies in particular to biometric data such as fingerprints, which entail an increased risk to the rights and freedoms of data subjects.

Furthermore, the consent forms grouped together various processing purposes, thereby failing to provide any opportunity to decide on the purposes separately. No distinction was made between the legally required processing of identification data and the optional processing of biometric data; consequently, in the authority’s view, the consent was neither specific to the particular case nor freely given. Furthermore, in the AZOP’s view, the information provided to players upon registration was contradictory and incomplete. For instance, fingerprints were used not only for identification but also, amongst other things, to control and monitor access to the premises, to protect minors, to facilitate participation in gambling, and for the bonus rewards programme. According to the authority, this meant that the data processing was not transparent to the data subjects. The authority concluded that the consents obtained from 34,933 players were invalid.

Norway

Fine of € 8.6 million imposed on Microsoft subsidiary ‘Xandr’ for selling sensitive data

On October 12, 2026, the Norwegian Data Protection Authority (Datatilsynet) imposed a record fine of 8,585,000 euros (92 million Norwegian kroner) on the Microsoft subsidiary ‘Xandr’. The advertising technology firm had processed sensitive data from users of the dating app ‘Grindr’ without a legal basis and passed it on to other companies (press release of 12.10.2026).

This is the highest single fine imposed by the Norwegian supervisory authority to date since the GDPR came into force. Although Norway is not a member of the EU, as a member of the European Economic Area it has fully transposed and integrated the GDPR into its national data protection law. 

The fine imposed by the supervisory authority stems from a complaint lodged by the Norwegian Consumer Council and the Austrian data protection organisation ‘NOYB’. 

Xandr had processed personal data collected by the dating app. The data included, amongst other things, information on users’ sexual orientation – which, like political opinions, religious affiliation or health status, is subject to special protection under the GDPR. 

The ad tech firm, acting as an online auctioneer of personal data, sold the data on to potentially thousands of companies for marketing purposes. Xandr denied any responsibility, placing the blame instead on the dating app itself. It claimed that the app operator had obtained prior consent from the data subjects for the further use of the data. However, this consent was declared invalid by the supervisory authority. The operator had failed to provide users with sufficient information. Furthermore, the Microsoft subsidiary shares joint responsibility under data protection law with the dating app operator, meaning that Xandr itself should also have verified the lawfulness of the consents. Back in 2021, the Norwegian supervisory authority had already imposed an administrative fine on the dating app operator.

The supervisory authority also pointed out that responsibility for data protection cannot be outsourced. Every business operator must verify the lawfulness of data collection and take responsibility for it accordingly.

Felix Sander

Wissenschaftlicher Mitarbeiter